Personal View site logo
War: Chronicles of 22.02.22 war
  • 266 Replies sorted by
  • The Washington Post reports that the US and allies are preparing a Ukrainian government-in-exile led by Zelensky, as they are counting on a protracted "bloody" guerrilla war with Russia.

    As usual, peace is very bad for US.

  • EU and US virtual pinky fighters for peace:

    image

    sa19510.jpg
    486 x 594 - 71K
  • @hardimpact So many people that I know hope for everything turns back 2019...it simply won't happenn

    @Dark_Blue there is still some sanity to this world.

  • The "evil" russians giving food and humanitarian aid to the civilians of Melitopol...

    Capture.PNG
    1557 x 877 - 2M
  • i hope peace comes soon.

  • Ultimately, putin made the decision and it can't be undone. He's what, 69 now? He is likely past caring about what people care about his actions. Focus on helping those in Ukraine that can be helped at this point instead of arguing over something that we can't change. I think Ukraine should surrender now and preserve life. Putin maybe miscalculated the sanctions or maybe he did not. He needs an exit that the west won't give to him since the Ukrainians are now cannon-fodder that serve the west only as a stumbling block for Russian military, and neither they nor their cities can survive this onslaught. Once the fighting stops, i would expect a stealth removal of sanctions that are squeezing the West since politicians are flip-floppers and the global economy is so near collapse. The press will slither out of their current narrative and memory-hole the entire affair as they go on to new topics.

  • @G3550D liked and subscribed. Don't take it to serious from my part ...life is miserable enough.

  • Current progress:

    image

    sa19509.jpg
    800 x 644 - 87K
  • @G3550D

    Don't rush. Just be gentle and careful. War is war, after all.

    With communities most people do same error as in marriage - they take it for granted, instead of nourishing it, supporting partners during hard times and keep the constant contact during good times.

    This illusion of endless choice is just bad illusion, as it is made by ruling class that is just cloning various shit and selling you different kind of it as real alternatives.

  • Thanks @G3550D for your viewpoint. I appreciated it. It is sad to see you go. I too will have to think carefully what I say on here due to the new law, in order to prevent trouble for this forum.

  • Hi Vitaly, Garroulous. After some thougbt I've decided to leave the forum. The new Russian Law leaves the possibility open that Vitaly could end up in jail if something I say is regarded as fake news and that is not a risk I want to take. I do try to tell the truth but I can get things wrong.

    I too am from the working class (though I am better off now) and always see politics in terms of their/our interests so it's a great pity that, in political terms, I can't agree with much of what you write.

    But Garroulous, I really am not an agent. (edit -I think you have accepted this) My real name is Stan Willis and I have a very average channel on youtube. In the unlikely event that you want to check out my saxophone playing, go back to the very first video 'Round Midnite'.

    Anyway, maybe some happier time in the future, if I am still around, I will look in again. Thanks to Vitaly for all his hard work over the years. Goodbye for now.

  • @RoadsidePicnic

    EU and US leading military professionals trained Nazis, aimed them with huge amount of modern weapons, provided millions of mines.

    Now NATO satellite intel is used to coordinate movement of Nazis forces and possible strikes.

    Action of western corporations, sports and culture organizations show coordinated Nazist actions. Where it is nation that is declared bad, that is target, not Putin.

  • Just to add, Ukraine post maidan is a coup state and nazism hub, with huge paramilitary nazist movement, thats been activelly spreading nazism and training nazist militants from arround the globe, fomenting nazist grip into third world countries. It's not this because putin said so, they themselves have been prolific using social media to boast about it for years long now.

    All that sweet talking here about russia should be noble looks a lot more like fear of the water thats already rised up to everyone asses. EU and USA upper and middle class are really not worried of Ukraine people well being, or russian people standards of life, the same way they dont care about third world and dont give a fuck about nazists spreading into third world with Ukraine hand.

  • @G3550D i apologize. But still Vitality explained quite clearly that it's not about Putin and we heard this name so many times that you should stop for a second and think for your self...otherwise stop coming with the same that we can see on most of the mass media.

  • The optimistic picture of the future that Vitaly presents is of a successful fit between Russia the producer of the raw materials and China the manufacturer. Normally this is the third world/developed world model. Unfortunately for you,if you have ever spoken to anyone that has travelled around Africa (and elsewhere I've heard), China is all over the place doing public works and securing future supplies of materials (particularly rare ones). Russia will have tied itself to China but I sense that China is already having concerns about the tail wagging the dog. Russia will be a price taker not a price setter. China will be your master.

    Russia could produce fine software engineers and try to compete with India but Vitaly's plan for mass pirating is going to limit their chances of selling to the huge market outside Russia and China. There are downsides to all illegal actions.

    If Putin remains in power, he may well be wanted for war crimes and crimes against humanity so Russia may become a pariah state with its citizens fighting over a diminishing cake. The poor cannot take much of a cut so the professional classes will have to take a large one. Start building the walls you are going to need.

    You will also be pouring resources into trying to control and rebuild a very large country which hates you and the cost of that will be colossal.

    Your separation from the cultural, scientific and sporting will take further joy from your lives. You will be building your own gigantic jail.

    That is the nightmare alternative to Vitaly's optimistic scenario. I really hope it doesn't come to that.

    Just stop the war now and remove the man responsible for it. European citizens do not yet see the Russian people as the enemy and perhaps we now can see and address the many problems you have. And, before you say it Vitaly, I know we are not perfect and we have a lot of problems of our own to sort out but war is not the answer.

  • @garroulus I have been on the site since the GH2 days. Don't start getting paranoid about special/secret agents. Vitaly has my brief details. I'm retired but I worked as a statistician and for a while as a musician. I previously have spent a lot of my time posting criticisms of my own government and Trump in the British press. But Putin's war is a massively dangerous mistake and I think that most intelligent people should be able to agree on that.

  • @AndrewReid_EOSHD

    Andrew - also keep in mind that from tomorrow any info that can be deemed fake information about war or anti war propaganda can have real and fast consequence to me and site. We are small, so no one cares much, but we better be safe, ok? I am not responsible for laws that capitalists make, so just live with that they do.

    So, keep yourself within bounds, as I don't want to censor anything, but will be forced to save PV.

  • @G3550D... you start to seem like some kind of special agent here as oposed @AndrewReid_EOSHD that i've been watching for years and i see that Vitality is very patient with you...your opinions we can see on msm every day...

  • Soon all Western exports to Russia and all shipping companies will completely stop. It will be really bad.

    Nope. It won't happen, as it is capitalist on both side. And all western exports are not much important except manufacturing equipment and chemical and components stuff. Software we'll pirate anyway.

    As citizens we should not wish each other ill-will, just because of history or nationalism. The original idea of socialism is not to punish normal people

    What this strange words mean?

    If Putin was a real patriot and interested in a stronger Russia, rather than being an egotistical lunatic, it's not obvious what his war is going to achieve for Russia other than isolation and complete economic collapse.

    Andrew, can we stop mentioning Puting and his lunatism in each post, please?

    Isn't it strange that 90% of people supported move of this guy? Same is true for largest part of ruling class.

    Isn't not obvious what his war is going to achieve for Russia other than isolation and complete economic collapse

    Stop wishful thinking.

    As our major imports are from countries that... surprise did not made any sanctions.

    It isn't even an honourable suicide. Nobody honourable kills themselves at the same time as cluster bombing women and children in their homes, and attacking nuclear power stations.

    Stop writing nonsense. Capitalist wars are horrible, this one also, but it is not suicide.

    Nuclear power station had been attacked by Ukraine idiots who such way tried to stop advancements.

    Russia, the sum of its people and its talent is far above that. Let them recognise this, wish them the ability to rise up and find new leadership, new ideas and take back control of their nation.

    Did you actually read even one line of that I wrote here for years?

    West and western companies destroyed almost all manufacturing, science and other stuff here. Just because it is much more profitable such way, no competition and you have open free market. Intentionally. And they loved us to live like in Bangladesh, if possible.

    So, country is rising up now. Issue is that it is under capitalism, so live with the methods your beloved social system, has.

  • @Vitaliy_Kiselev Soon all Western exports to Russia and all shipping companies will completely stop. It will be really bad. As citizens we should not wish each other ill-will, just because of history or nationalism. The original idea of socialism is not to punish normal people. If Putin was a real patriot and interested in a stronger Russia, rather than being an egotistical lunatic, it's not obvious what his war is going to achieve for Russia other than isolation and complete economic collapse. It could be 1989 all over again. Whatever grievances are left over from the Soviet times, it isn't worth suicide. It isn't even an honourable suicide. Nobody honourable kills themselves at the same time as cluster bombing women and children in their homes, and attacking nuclear power stations. It's a shit hill to die on. Russia, the sum of its people and its talent is far above that. Let them recognise this, wish them the ability to rise up and find new leadership, new ideas and take back control of their nation.

  • @G3550D I see what you're saying and my proposal is entirely from an amateurish perspective and politically unrealistic - but at times of crisis no option should be off the table, even extreme ones like this. It's not so much about disbanding NATO but removing the US influence from NATO and working with Russia diplomatically. Putting more EU-27 funding into defence budgets here rather than relying on the US. But before I begin to sound like Trump, there is more to it than just that. It has to be combined with agreeing some common ground with Russia to keep the US military out of Europe. On top of that, there will be a unified EU armed forces, a larger combined military power from our side. Unless Putin's end-goal is to demilitarise the entirety of Europe and make us all like Finland but in poverty, he should accept proposals to reduce US influence and military presence in Europe with open arms, in return for ending his war with Ukraine. We are not the Russian people's enemy in the EU. It is no good relying on a huge Russian foe to guarantee our safety on the border with Russia! All they do is guarantee our mutual destruction. And what is the point of NATO anyway if they are so powerless, they can't even give Ukraine a no fly zone without triggering WW3? The moment Putin goes into a NATO country, the US and Russia will obliterate Europe. The US will walk away as winners and have a post-WW2 style economic surge. The Russians will walk away with millions of deaths on their hands like the Nazis. Nobody wants it. NATO is a deeply flawed concept.

  • @Vitaly We hear today that Russian citizens are at risk of being imprisoned if they use the words 'war' or invasion' instead of the phrase 'Special Military Operation'. Can I suggest that you and any Russian contributor use that phrase from now on and I hope that nobody criticizes you for it. The rest of us can still use what words we choose as we are not at risk of being thrown into jail. Tragic times for your country and the Ukraine.

    The American ABC report is only a little surprising. Putin is beating the patriotic drum and allowing no access to foreign news or demonstrations.The time he will worry is when the soldiers start coming home. Will the big parades and freshly printed devalued Roubles be enough for them to forget what they have witnessed?

    @Andrew It is unrealistic now to expect Hungary, Poland etc to be satisfied with promises from Putin that he will not invade them. Disbanding Nato at this time would cement Putin's hold on power and that would be a tragedy for all of us, including the long suffering Russian people. Nato's policy of only putting a red line around Nato states but allowing individual states to supply Ukraine seems about right to me even though it is not a policy to be proud of.

    It is a truly awful position to be in, but we can only rely on there being enough sane people in the Russian Government to stop Putin if he tries to bring everything down with him. But Putin has family(s) as well as the rest of us and I don't think he is yet anywhere near being in the mindset of those who poisoned their children in the last days of Hitler's bunker.

  • Specially for Andrew:

    The film crew of the American ABC News visited the Moscow region, the journalist discussed the current situation in the world with local residents and was surprised.

    They are convinced that Russia is now waging something like the Great Patriotic War in Ukraine. This is the first. And the second thing... and they made it very clear to me... they don't really mind the consequences. And more than that, welcome them.

    I asked if they weren't worried that Russia would be cut off from everything and that those times would return when their country had no connection with the outside world... But no, that doesn't bother them. Against. They are even happy about it.

  • @AndrewReid_EOSHD

    In my opinion the UK, France and Germany have to end NATO and build their OWN army on their OWN terms.

    You understand that NATO idea has been exactly to avoid new WWIII? By keeping UK and EU under US supervision and not allow them to fight each other.

    All this racism and nationalism you see now in US, UK and EU is because ruling class of this countries translates his wishes. And they want, due to resource shortage to disband any democratic masks and install fascism again.

    I am sure Joe Biden is a moral man, a good person, but since this war began, he and fellow politicians at Capitol Hill have done nothing but pat themselves on the back, whilst thousands of innocent civilians are blown leg from limb. I was disgusted to watch the State of the Union address. At a time of huge peril and tragedy for the world, the Americans were jerking themselves off. “Look how great we are”.

    And stop all this "Biden this", "Macron is such"...

    Look at ruling class core economic interests and all will be clear.