Manfrotto 561BHDV-1 Fluid Video Monopod with Head. Any good?

jimtreats

@LPowell thanks... hmm. I don't know what to do then, perhaps look into other options, i'd seen such good reviews of that manfrotto one, but i take your warning of uselessness very seriously. Well there's no stock anyways so plenty of time to weigh up my options.

LPowell

@jimtreats
I found the rotating cartridge at the base of the Manfrotto monopod to be useless. It had enough internal friction damping to twist the thinnest extension rod of the monopod. This would cause slight glitches in the panning action, which ruined the smoothness of the pan. To fix it, I inserted thin washers in the mounting screws of the ball joint footplate, enabling the ball joint to rotate freely instead of the fluid-damped cartridge.

jimtreats

@shrigg do you experience any problems with twisting with the panning head at the top of the monopod? The manfrotto one I originally linked to has the panning done at the base of the monopod, arguing that it removes problems of twisting when that motion is performed at the top. Having never tried it, i'm taking their word on it being a problem worth solving.

shrigg

Here's a simpler setup using just a 503HDV head atop my Manfrotto monopod.

jimtreats

Thanks @oscillian, I tried ordering the manfrotto model but there is no stock in the UK at the moment. Their factories are off for the summer apparently!!!

oscillian

The Weifeng seems to have a rubber foot to keep it in place:
Rather good price here: http://www.proav.co.uk/Brands/E-image/Monopods/br1119_c494_p27918_Specification.aspx

oscillian

Maybe this would do the trick on a budget: pan/tilt-head, 178cm with a footstep bracket to keep it from rocking if necessary. If the head comes off you could replace it with a 717.

http://viewitem.eim.ebay.se/BRAND-NEW-5FT-10-VIDEO-STILL-DIGITAL-CAMERA-MONOPOD/310274726508/item

or the Weifeng version with footstep bracket:

http://global.rakuten.com/en/store/gorilla55/item/al3-5/
http://www.dinodirect.com/monopod-weifeng-wt1005.html

Anyone who's tried this kind of bracket technique?

PixCanFly

I think the 3 small feet on the Manfrotto 561BHDV makes a big different.

Chrispy

The Manfrotto 561BHDV is a great kit. I've had mine for about two years. Works great when shooting in crowds since it doesn't use up as much room as a tripod. we sell a lot of them where I work also. www.GlazersCamera.com

chip

Thanks Shrigg!

jimtreats

I believe the one i linked is one of the few to have feet, but more importantly I believe that the fluid head atop the monopod is different to what you'd expect. The panning action is locked in the head, rather its built into the base element of the monopod.. as such you're meant to not get excessive undesirable twisting that you would get with a traditional head on top of a monopod.

This design seemed to me to be quite neat, and unique. Do other monopods offer this?

Thanks for the alternative suggestions and discussions...

last_SHIFT

So is Manfrotto the only one with the feet?

Vitaliy_Kiselev

Weifeng solutions use 717 head.

jo447

I didn't like the head, so I bought the manfrotto 562. I took off the manfrotto plate and put a wf717 instead and add the manfrotto plate on the top of my head so I can still move my gh2 quickly from my rig to my monopod.
you can see a video here where I used it

Aria

@ Shrigg, hey man that's cool a heck! I like the top hot shoe locking aspect of the cage. I like the size and love the price. I don't have my GH2 yet, been using but when I do i'm gonna order one of your cages. I love supporting small businesses so that's an added plus for me.

shrigg

It's the Shrigg Jig production cage that I designed a few months ago. Now they are being manufactured and sold here in the USA for $99.

Aria

@shrigg what is that little cage you have around your GH2?

shrigg

@chip

I know it's a Manfrotto but can't find a number on it anywhere. It accepts either a 100mm or 75mm ball head. Bought it a few years ago, I assume they still make it... Here it is with my GH2 atop a 75mm Cartoni head

chip

Shrigg,

that really looks interesting, what ball head coupler do you use?

last_SHIFT

I have the Manfrotto - got the one with the plate as I already have a 701. I absolutely love it, I wish it would collapse just a bit lower though.

PixCanFly

The Manfrotto 561 BHDV-1 is a very good video monopod, value for money. Go for it!
You might also want to consider the 562B-1 if you already have a small video head lying around, like a Manfrotto 501,701 or something.
http://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/757124-REG/Manfrotto_562B_1_Fluid_Video_Aluminum_4_Section.html
It's much cheaper and it's the same monopod except for the modified Manfrotto 701 on the 561 BHDV-1.
Just swap out the video head.

Vitaliy_Kiselev

@shrigg
Interesting idea.

shrigg

That video shows some great monopod techniques. Sure you can rotate the monopod to pan, but a good fluid head is key in tilting. I use the heavy duty manfrotto monopod along with a ball head coupler so I can use any 75mm ball head. Works just like the $300 561BHDV-1 in the video but far cheaper... much quicker to use than a tripod, perfect for run and gun.

Vitaliy_Kiselev

I have one like this
http://cgi.ebay.com/Aluminium-Lightweight-71-Camera-Monopod-3way-head-/110422375449
Second cheapest Weifeng model as I know.

Do not use it much. But like extra cheap plastic head with handle for it's weight and you can really improve results with tele lenses.

May be will get this one in future (as it is long and sturdy)

http://cgi.ebay.com/CF-Graphite-Carbon-Fiber-Fibre-Monopod-FT-1603-FT1603-/200620446975

brianluce

Although, if the 561BHDV comes with that blonde, I'd probably go ahead and get it.

Howdy, Stranger!

Categories

Tags in Topic

Top Posters