Personal View site logo
Right to repair topic
  • 55 Replies sorted by
  • Why they support it?

    Because they are small niche guys, it does not touch them financially and instead it is nice totally free advertisement. So, totally pragmatic approach.

    Just need to remember that most board for their notes are being designed and made by same Taiwan firms, who also own all right for them.

  • Finally not so bad idea.

    Mostly it is good to realize how far this guys outweigh you in the money department, will teach few lessons.

  • And idea seems to more or less work for now

  • Not understanding that in capitalism you can't have any right to repair is really sad.

  • And petty bourgeoisie is always the same, same errors and same stupid hopes.

  • Small, but fast growing, shark can't fight openly about intellectual property, just scared.

  • Still banging poor head on the closed door.

  • And they are doing this because.... bad people again?

    Nope, it is because it is for profit capitalist companies who see enemy in everyone, including all of their customers.

  • Most fun stuff is that in exact this moment Louis packs and leaves NY to be very far.

    In reality it can be direct order where powerful proper people asked him not to interfere and not ruin the stuff.

  • Nice, something real.

  • President Joe Biden will direct the U.S. Federal Trade Commission to draft new rules aimed at stopping manufacturers from limiting consumers’ ability to repair products at independent shops or on their own, a person familiar with the plan said.

    While the agency will ultimately decide the size and scope of the order, the presidential right-to-repair directive is expected to mention mobile phone manufacturers and Department of Defense contractors as possible areas for regulation. Tech companies including Apple Inc. and Microsoft Corp. have imposed limits on who can repair broken consumer electronics like game consoles and mobile phones, which consumer advocates say increases repair costs.

    The order is also expected to benefit farmers, who face expensive repair costs from tractor manufacturers who use proprietary repair tools, software, and diagnostics to prevent third-parties from working on the equipment, according to the person, who requested anonymity to discuss the action ahead of its official announcement.

    The executive order, which is expected to be released in the coming days, is broadly designed to drive “greater competition in the economy, in service of lower prices for American families and higher wages for American workers,” White House economic adviser Brian Deese said Friday.

    https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-07-06/biden-wants-farmers-to-have-right-to-repair-own-equipment-kqs66nov

    Now bureaucracy wants to protect corporations, similar to EU.

  • "I am so busy with so many other things in my life that I haven't really gotten involved in that area. But I'm always totally supportive and I totally think the people behind it (the Right to Repair) are doing the right thing," said Wozniak

    What this guy is so busy with? What of this is so useful to humanity? I just don't see any.

  • (ii) unfair anticompetitive restrictions on third-party repair or self-repair of items, such as the restrictions imposed by powerful manufacturers that prevent farmers from repairing their own equipment;

    https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/presidential-actions/2021/07/09/executive-order-on-promoting-competition-in-the-american-economy/

    Nice wish list that will result in nothing.

  • Order is not about Right to repair, despite all the PR stunts.

  • Someone explained to Louis small parts on how law system works.

    Hope that soon someone smart will tell him that his wishes are impossible in capitalism.

    This will be next painful stage.

  • IFixit Co-Founder and CEO Kyle Wiens talked about how companies like Apple, Samsung, and Microsoft are working hard to prevent their products from being repaired. They design their devices and manipulate the supply chain to limit the access of consumers and third-party service centers to the parts and tools needed to repair products such as smartphones, laptops, and more.

    Vines gave specific examples of how some large tech companies have prevented users from repairing their devices themselves. For example, the German company Varta, which supplies batteries for Samsung headphones, when asked to sell a battery for self-repair, says that the contract with Samsung completely excludes this possibility.

    Similar problems arise when repairing Apple products. So the MacBook Pro has a special charging controller chip that is produced by a third-party company, but no one can buy it except Apple itself. In addition, Vines said he is aware that Apple has contracted a California facility to recycle parts for its products, many of which are brand new. We are talking about unused stock of parts for devices that have ended.

    He talked about one of the Microsoft laptop models, in which the battery is glued with super-strong glue, which makes it absolutely impossible to replace it. When trying to remove the battery from this device, iFixit experts completely destroyed its case.

    Vines proposed requiring electronics manufacturers to introduce a repairability labeling scheme similar to those used in France and Australia.

    Anything is ok, just never tell that the king is naked. Sorry, that capitalism will always repeat this things again and again. As it brings maximal profits.

  • The Federal Trade Commission formally pledged to take on unlawful “right to repair” restrictions in a new policy statement issued Wednesday.

    Wednesday’s new right to repair policy statement commits the FTC to encouraging competition in product repair markets with “vigor,” according to Chair Lina Khan. The statement, which was approved unanimously, makes it official FTC policy for the agency to use its existing authorities to support independent repair shops and lower repair costs for consumers.

    “While efforts by dominant firms to restrict repair markets are not new, changes in technology and more prevalent use of software has created fresh opportunities for companies to limit independent repair,” Khan said Wednesday. “These types of restrictions can significantly raise costs for consumers, stifle innovation, close off business opportunities for independent repair shops, create unnecessary electronic waste, delay timely repairs, and undermine resiliency.

    So, let me remind you about most important foundation of capitalism:

    Law is the will of the ruling class transformed into legal regulations.

    So, it is nothing unlawful in that Apple is doing or Google or anyone else similar. As they are the boss, they are the ruling class and they are setting the laws.

    Do not make ant FTC statements fool you, this guys will be doing same thing and much worse in 2022.

  • Louis got all things wrong.