Personal View site logo
True Detective (TV Series)
  • It's just amazing.

    Let's have a topic about it!

  • 30 Replies sorted by
  • Well we're 2 episodes into 2nd season and what a let down :-(

    When I first saw Vaughan cast as one of the bad guys my spine twirled, but it's worse than that. WTF with the repetitive and quite boring establishing shots and (maybe with the exception of Farrell) with the odd and soft choosing of actors?!!! Ok sweaty McAdams has a big behind and there's some pretty latin ladies (who actually can act) but almost all supporting roles are more interesting and solidly carried out than main characters: the girl with big scar on the face, the alcoholic mayor drinking directly from the cocktail mixer (Ritchie Coster), the devious mom with herpes (Lolita Davidovich)...

    The gap is ever so more evident 'cause, despite all its compromises and holes, season 1 was one of the best tv shows out there, with stellar performances. IMO the only thing that's a bit redeeming in this new delivery are intro titles (good follow up of previous, ST's Leonard Cohen’s Nevermind) and having T. Bone Burnett as music supervisor.

     

  • @robertGl

    "@Jean71 why are you so upset by my opinion of the show? I could go into detail why I find the show pretentious and overrated, but that would take extra work, and it would accomplish nothing because fanboys will never accept any criticism that makes their beloved show seem less than what they believe it to be"

    If you don't have the "extra time" for "extra work" i accept it.

    But details are always welcome since this is a community, and as i said before, if you are negative towards everything, that is of no help, and neither a contribute to the community. So don't worry about fanboys, and since we are there, you can also explain the technical problems of Dragon Sensor, since you wrote "Meh" and people from CML and ASC are testing it, and major directors and DP's, academy winners too, are already using it for big budget movies.

    Please go into details, we are here to share and learn, and it's possible i can learn something based on your technical analysis on sensors and tv shows.

  • If all we have is hyperbole then it's fair game on both sides.

  • Oh, come on, guys. King Lear is a masterpiece. So are the late Beethoven quartets. Love or hate "True Detective", but it's not life-changing, the highest expression of human creativity or a monument of Western culture. And it has many, many antecedents.

    For the record, I'm neither, Christian, southern, Republican, or any combination thereof.

  • (sniff, sniff) I smell Christian, Southern, Republican, some combination of the three or some aspect closely related. Maybe, maybe not.

    Haters tend to have underlying reasons for their criticism.

  • @Jean71 why are you so upset by my opinion of the show? I could go into detail why I find the show pretentious and overrated, but that would take extra work, and it would accomplish nothing because fanboys will never accept any criticism that makes their beloved show seem less than what they believe it to be

  • No, I'll get a life eventually, just it's annoying to just pop in the thread and drop a line or two regardless of what has been already talked about. You are welcome to join the conversation but try to check out where it got by now.

  • @inqbt8tr I see what you mean...

    Is there something that is gnaw at you?

    BTW you did not reference any source... Just get a life

  • @LongJohnSilver

    It is not a 50 pages thread, only few posts up there is that same information you have posted.

  • Most of the shots are 35mm kodak film with few digital exceptions. Nice description of lens used.

    Arkapaw shot primarily on 35mm film—Kodak Vision 3 50D and 500T—and used two different sets of lenses to help differentiate the two time periods. He used Panavision PVintage optics—rehoused Panavision Ultra Speed prime lenses—for the main portion of the story and regular Primo primes for the contemporary portions. “It’s about recalling the past,” the cinematographer explains, “so we wanted all that footage to be shot through something suggesting a thin veil of time. Those older lenses are a little softer, less contrasty and [capture] a little less color.”

    http://www.creativeplanetnetwork.com/dv/feature/crime-scenes-creative-storytelling-production-hbos-true-detective/65219

  • @robertGl

    "So far only saw the first episode.. not too impressed. Didn't like the dialogues/monologues, McConaughey is really annoying, and I don't know how his character could ever make detective with his attitude."

    First time i post a Dragon footage, your reply was: "Meh".

    Now we are speaking about a masterpiece in scriptwriting, shooting, editing and actor's performances, and you are finding all of this "annoying".

    I don't want to open a worm can here, given your negative attitude on almost everything good, but it would be useful to see a thread, opened by you, with things that you like and movies, dialogues, tv series that catch up with your taste. Just to realize why you are so negative towards some things.

    Critics must be constructive, i find the nihilism very near to the nonsense.

    No offense, i think some tips about what you like can be useful, just to understand "particular people's point of views" in a constructive way.

  • Hahah. Maybe the police got pre-production one to test it :)

  • Started to see it today. Amazing.

    And found a little error by the production: the camera that are used to record the interviews for both the cops is a NEX-5r (identifiable for the details in the grip, by the strap lugs, and the position of the image in the LCD), which was announced in August, 2012 - and date in these scenes are in May, 2012. :)

  • Interview with Nic Pizzolatto

    Three years ago, Nic Pizzolatto was an assistant professor of literature at DePauw University in Indiana, a job he "fell into" rather than loved, and one he was desperate to escape. Television seemed like an impossible dream. "The idea was ludicrous," he says. "I grew up in a working-class Catholic family in south Louisiana. I went to a state university. I taught literature, wrote a novel that was the novel I wanted to write and got a couple of good reviews but no real traction. I had no idea how to get a job in TV."

    http://www.theguardian.com/tv-and-radio/2014/feb/17/true-detective-nic-pizzolatto-mcconaughey-harrelson

  • It's not surprising a better story can be told over 8 hours of TV than 2 hours of a movie. So much more time to develop characters and story.

  • TV has now surpassed conventional commercial filmmaking for quality writing and stories

    The reason is pretty simple. TV -- at least some corners of it -- is above all a writers' medium, unlike either commercial filmmaking or so-called American indies, and draws on people who can actually write, who often come to the work from the novel, rather than from the screenplay or "movie" business.

  • That tracking scene was amazing. This is some of the best work that's ever been done for television. TV has now surpassed conventional commercial filmmaking for quality writing and stories, by a wide margin.

  • Up there with "The Wire"

  • I only watch it for Alexandra Daddario. Wowzers!

  • Fifth episode was my favorite of the whole series so far. I am extremely impressed with this show.

  • This series is fantastic. Screenplay and dialogue are absolutely amazing

  • The tracking shot from episode 4 - just extraordinary

  • I'm a little tired of the weird serial killer genre, but I'm digging the show. Sorta reminds me of The Killing. Which was very solid. (Not sure if it's coming back) McConaughey is finally living up to some of his early career hype as being the next Newman or whatever. He almost killed his career off as an actor with crappy rom coms. His last 2-3 years have been excellent.