Personal View site logo
Make sure to join PV on Telegram or Facebook! Perfect to keep up with community on your smartphone.
Please, support PV!
It allows to keep PV going, with more focus towards AI, but keeping be one of the few truly independent places.
24p25p-NINE - GOP9 Hack for friendly co-existance of 24p and 25p
  • 65 Replies sorted by
  • TomasoTomaso

    @towi Did you test SH and H in PAL? Your settings from the day before did work fine.

  • towitowi

    "Did you test SH and H in PAL? Your settings from the day before did work fine" - strange ... they are exactly the same settings except of the GOP-setting for 1080i60. I've tested 720p50 in PAL mode. SH only, though.

    If you use PAL mode maybe just reload these settings (March, 3rd): http://www.personal-view.com/talks/discussion/comment/45642#Comment_45642

  • mickosmickos

    Just used 24p25p on a 48hour film challenge needing 25p - it performed superbly! It was 7 minute one-shot genre - and only one scary "Recording cancelled" occurred - when the battery was almost flat. Fresh batteries and another 10 takes and no problems. Having 1h53m available on a 32Gb card was a bonus and the raw footage looked great (-2,-2,-2,-2 24p25p-NINE_HQMatrix_66M36M). Thanks Towi

  • towitowi

    @mickos

    cool! I am glad someone actually used the setting.

    I've stopped working on 24p25p-NINE as I couldn't solve the issue with PCR- and Clip-Duration. Also motion doesn't look that good... But for tableau-style work / static scenes it's great!

    Maybe I'll further improve this 9GOP setting at a later time.

    Here's another setting (just finished) for the very same purposes. It's good old Sanity V3.1 with the HQ Matrix and some other modifications applied.

    HBRp25_chart_static_Frames.PNG
    746 x 412 - 43K
    HBRp25_motion_Time.PNG
    746 x 286 - 44K
    HBRp25_motion.jpg
    649 x 394 - 69K
    24H_chart_static_Frames.PNG
    746 x 412 - 43K
    24h_motion_Time.PNG
    746 x 286 - 44K
    _setb_22_SANITY_V3_modified_PAL_HQ.zip
    1K
  • towitowi

    "Maybe I'll further improve this 9GOP setting at a later time"

    okay.... an update is in the works and will be released soon (25p already works fine) ...

  • mickosmickos

    From the short using 24p25p-NINE footage, 7-14mm on GH2. Can't post the film as in judging. Thanks again!

    00006_24.05.2012 1.09.22 AM.png
    1920 x 1080 - 3M
  • carlesmbcarlesmb

    Sorry in advance for my newbiest. I'm looking for a 1080/25p patch and I tested a few of it in HBR mode like LPowell Flowmotion or Quantum. When I insert one clip recorded in HBR in the StreamParser, the stream modeit is 1080/50i either in 24p25p-NINE as can I view in the screenprints.

    Adobe Premiere (for example) don't recognize the progressive mode, an says that is interlaced. Anyone can help me? Thks

  • G3550DG3550D

    Had the same problem myself found this answer on this forum...

    I'm looking for a 1080/25p patch and I tested a few of it in HBR mode like LPowell Flowmotion 1.1 or Quantum. When I insert one clip recorded in HBR in the StreamParser, the stream mode say that it is 1080/50i, and this is usual as can I view in the users screenprints of another patchs. Adobe Premiere (for example) don't recognize the progressive mode, an says that is interlaced. Anyone can help me? Thks

    nomad July 14 You'll need to "lie" to the NLE. HBR is progressive footage (i.e. from every 25th of a second) but encoded as interlace.

  • franfran

    but, how lie to the NLE? for example FCP? droping the footage on 25p TL?

  • inqb8trinqb8tr

    @fran It is 25p wrapped in 50i. You need to force your NLE to treat it as 25p. In premiere you use "Interpret footage". In FCP (not sure about fcpx) you Conform footage using cinematools

  • franfran

    @inqb8tr Aha, ok. So I should start a progresive projet 25p, and then get my GH2 footage in the browser and interpret it like true 25p. If I do this the Time line won´t force me to render. That´s right? I think in final cut would be necesary to use Cinema tools and confrom to 25p. I will do and will say if it works. Thanks inqb8tr

  • inqb8trinqb8tr

    @fran Yes, that's the way.

  • franfran

    Thanks inqb8tr! I will try!

  • FlacnvinylFlacnvinyl

    So where do we stand on all of this? Is HBR25p solid in PAL land?

  • towitowi

    these patches are solid in HBR/25p (& FSH/50i):

    GOLGOP13-A: http://www.personal-view.com/talks/discussion/comment/91015#Comment_91015

    Sainty 3: http://www.personal-view.com/talks/discussion/comment/63791#Comment_63791

    Sanity 3 modified (HQ Matrix): http://www.personal-view.com/talks/discussion/comment/63801#Comment_63801

    Sanity 5: http://www.personal-view.com/talks/discussion/2642/sanity-4-and-5/p1 (not tested by myself but I think it's stable)

Add a Comment