Personal View site logo
Make sure to join PV on Telegram or Facebook! Perfect to keep up with community on your smartphone.
Portugal's message to Germany
  • I found this video has a very interesting message, from the people of Portugal to the people of Germany.

  • 21 Replies sorted by
  • Very interesting, thank you for posting.

  • Have to be careful about blaming stuff on Germany. Last time europe did that, it didn't work out too good.

  • This is such BS.. The Germans worked and made stuff. Other people bought these things. Now the argument is that Germany needs to pay money to people who have been irresponsible with their own finances. A trade deficit is not by choice, its a way that free markets impose efficiency. The country running a trade deficit ultimately has to reduce its consumption or increase its production. This is done either via currency depreciation or a reduction of salaries or simply a reduction of consumption. The arguments of the deficit add to the logic that the ECB needs to be abolished and individual sovereigns allowed to have their own currency again. The ECB sets random limits which carry no weight. the ECB is pointless!

    The German default on East German debt is not a proper comparison - technically East Germany stopped existing in its earlier form. Even if not, its just an argument against allowing governments to accumulate debt. I cant believe this kind of BS is being propagated!

  • Yep its ridiculous. German tax payers paid several billion euros already to greece. while many german communities, including the city i live in, are bancrupt. I live in a 130000 people city that has debts of 750 million euros! the city had to sell every historic building years ago.

    the people of those countries have to go for the corrupt politicians and their bloated administrations. many people here pay more than 40 % income taxes.

    and how can you blame people for being innovative and productive? "hello, we are less innovative, pay less taxes, work less, give us your money!"? Portugese people should start being innovative, develope things that export themselves. capitalism can be ugly, but they wanted to participate in that, so now please dont cry and blame everybody else.

    dont get me wrong, i am not a fan of capitalism. but if you want to play a certain game, then dont cry about the rules later.

  • The country running a trade deficit ultimately has to reduce its consumption or increase its production. This is done either via currency depreciation or a reduction of salaries or simply a reduction of consumption.

    Yup, there is no mechanism for currency depreciation for countries in the Euro. There was, I understand, the belief that internal devaluation would take care of the deficits but it didn't seem to happen.

    One question I have though - how do other large areas with a single currency (i.e. the US) deal with internal trade deficits?

  • how do other large areas with a single currency (i.e. the US) deal with internal trade deficits?

    Quite simple. They print more money.

  • Germany achieve what Hitler didn't, Hitler was one of the worst peolple in history, but in some months with the help of banks control almost all Europe letting people starving and kill themselves. They want to control everything and they will be the most earning, and the rest of Europe are the poor and work for then for 1$

  • It is interesting to see how it is proven time and again that loaning money never makes friends.

    @unnamednm: So I guess you think as part of an evil plan Germans forced southern European countries to overspend and take credits? Bizarre. Regarding Hitler, have a look at Godwin's Law.

    It's really ridiculous to blame Germany for being too productive, but there are always two parties involved in a credit contract, and as much as I think the bankrupt countries deserve to default, the (individual/private and institutional) creditors who blindly loaned excessive amounts of money to those countries deserve to be reminded that there is a risk of not being paid back if your greed for interest earnings is bigger than your wits.

  • I thought as a textbook example of a piece of propaganda this was an excellent film. It really is very selective about the facts, then puts it together with a clever story idea, interesting visuals, and good soundtrack (which was also done in German and Portuguese too.)

    What do you think? Propaganda or documentary? :-)

  • Anyone know who sponsored it?

  • @ahbleza

    It is not really important. I mean all this goverment debt.

    As goverment debt was not accidental, but planned.

    We know main target, but wide audience does not know exact how this debt will be used by elites to move forward.

  • I feel I have the need to say something here as being Portuguese and living in Portugal I'm feeling like a moving target for this Government.

    I considered myself to be middle class (~2000€ gross wage) but I have to say that after the Government is done with taxes (Social security, IRS, VAT, home owner taxes, car taxes and municipality taxes) these days a lot less than 50% of my wage ends up in my pocket. The big chunk (~500€) of that remaining goes to the bank to pay my house which is the only thing I OWE. I do own 1 credit card which was imposed by the bank so I could have a 0.25% spread over Euribor on the interest rate. I never use it.

    My biggest consumerist sin was buying an used GH2 for 600€ from an Englishman living in Spain last year, an Olympus 45mm F1.8 for around 260€ and a Samyang 7.5mm FE for 320€ this year. Those are the most expensive pieces of equipment I own if I don't count the body.

    All this to say I've been conservative all my life about my spending and very cautious about my debts. I've nearly made a break even this year. Next year the Government budget it's going to be a lot harder on taxes to everyone. I'm lucky enough that I have some savings I can move, but the early economic signs are pointing so that this "good German student" road the Government is taking will worsen in 2014.

    Every economy expert in Portugal (and most of them outside, including the IMF) sees and says that this Government austerity measures will kill the economy and soon we will follow Greece (even though we've been adamant about implementing the austerity measures so far). When 9% of the country's budget alone is being spent on paying interest rates on the debt, and while all this is happening, Portugal is paying 3.5% interest rate on the debt to the banks (most of them German) who finance themselves at 1% from the ECB, I believe we have to pass a message, which is:

    "We want to pay! But we need more time to adjust and we need to pay less interest. Otherwise our Economy will be dead soon and then we can't pay at all."

    This is the message that the Chanceler isn't receiving.

    As @Mirrorkisser has put it I don't blame it on the Germans, I also believe we "have to go for the corrupt politicians and their bloated administrations" but: then... Ferrostaal president got indited (and I believe possibly convicted) in Germany for corruption of Portuguese authorities while shoving 2 german U-Boats up our asses, you know what happened here? We can't start a trial because the buying documentation was lost... And what happened to the Portuguese Defense Minister at the time? He's the leader of the smaller Party on the coalition that forms the current Government. Now he's the Minister of Foreign Affairs. How's that for irony? And how do people vote for him, you ask me? I don't ty to understand anymore, I just try to live responsibly in this place, but I figure he's a political zombie, every now and then everyone thinks he's dead (like when he regarded as suspect gay peadophile) but then he manages to come back from the dead with some cunning demagogy which he masters like no one else here. So how do we let them do it? In the end I believe (as I think @Vitaliy_Kiselev hinted) it all comes back to this: the BANKS control the Government who controls the pEOPLE.

    Anyway I've attended every demonstration there was to attend (except for this last one against Merkel, which I believe is probably acting on pre-election mode and pro-Germany when she should be pro-Europe) as I feel it's not in her hands anymore but on the Kaput all, oh sorry, I meant Capital.

    I also believe I should stop with politics right now and put up a related video shot with the GH3, Samyang 7.5mm FE, defished to Panini projection using Hugin, stabilized using After Effects and CCed using @shian Storm's ColorGHear TOOLKIT.

    (I've been waiting for over a full day for the FHD version to be processed, so there's only this HD one so far)

    I know, I know, the shadows are too noisy but I couldn't crush them anymore, the fucking Goverment has already done a bloody good job on these kids... :(

  • Absolute impudence: the debt and cheat countries of the monetary union are complaining about Germany: a bad joke: Germany financed the Union - unfortunately! no German money - there is no EU - the introduction of the euro was the biggest mistake in a hundred years - the southern countries, such as Greece, Spain, Portugal and Italy should go back to the old currencies to ever lanfristig to get out of debt - The EU is not a democracy - the topfunktionäre are not elected, but used - a German voice in elections to the European Parlament does not count as a vote, but only for a fraction - a joke, but true - I wish that Germany is out of the EU and, together with Russia, Japan and China, a global alliance against "Goldman Sachs" . . .

  • @duartix

    In fact, all that we see now is transformation of independent central banks system into some non national, completely independent (even by the name) financial system.

    I also have my own theory that timing is directly related with smartphones and data cellular networks propagation. As both this things are core to either dominance or destruction of current system.

  • together with Russia, Japan and China, a global alliance against "Goldman Sachs" . . .

    You mean after US-Japan war? As Japan is still occupied and fully controlled.

  • @Vitaliy Ok, ohne Japan . . . ggf. mit Indien ;) - Ok, Excluding Japan, possibly with India - and a descendant of Gandhi should lead us

    MKGandhi.jpg
    200 x 242 - 13K
  • Mostly i consider myself a pacifist and humanist. But sometimes i think the guillotine was not such a bad idea. Or like in the russian Revolution. If some people are to powerful and you can not get them out of the system, for the top managers of goldman sachs, super corrupt politicians who only feed their own pockets, a guillotine might be a humanist painless way to get rid of them. First one could confiscate and donate their belongings to the public. OR maybe a gulag? But then this all sounds too much like the russian or french revolution. But then again, it worked, so why not :) ?

  • @Mirrorkisser

    You are not fighting with top people only.
    Fight will be with quite large number of people. Owners and managers of banks, medical corporations and institutions, many educational sites, owners of big land parts, plus big numbers of people who never did anything useful.

  • @vitaliy so you need many guillotines and big gulags :)

    If it is for a greater benefit even bigger sacrifices might be justified.

  • @unnamednm

    What a strange comment, ever been to Germany in this century?

  • What a BS video. Do really Portugese people think in that way?